You've been writing with AI. Something about the drafts feels off, and you haven't been able to name it.

A free prompt system that makes your AI interview you instead of writing for you.

Cover of 'What Machines Can't Replace' by Anna McPhee

Most writers who use AI arrive at the same feeling eventually. The draft comes back right but not quite alive. The structure is fine, the argument holds, but the specific texture of your thinking has been smoothed away into something that could have come from anyone.

AI writes well, which is precisely where the trouble starts. It produces something competent enough to accept, and accepting it is easy, and that's where the drift happens, in the reasonable choice that mostly works.

I wrote this book with AI. It took months to find a way that kept the writing mine. The thing that changed it was simple: I stopped asking my AI to write and started asking it to ask me questions instead.

The Heartbeat Prompt System

The system has five questions, each serving a different part of a piece of writing.

Scene asks you to go back into a specific moment and describe it — what it looked like, what it smelt like, the particular texture of it. Not why it matters. Just what it was.

Expand asks you to connect that moment to the larger idea you're circling.

Research asks which evidence, which study, which other person's experience speaks to what you just described.

Meaning asks what all of this adds up to, the one thing you're actually trying to say.

Practical asks how a reader uses what you've written, what it gives them that they couldn't find elsewhere.

Your AI asks these one at a time and waits for your answer before moving on. Then you give it everything you said and ask it to build from your material, not from scratch. What comes out is yours, because you generated it, and the AI held the space while you found it.

About the book

What Machines Can't Replace explores what happens to human creativity when AI can do the technical parts. The argument, built from research and personal failure in roughly equal measure, is that AI is clarifying what human creativity actually is, by showing what it can and cannot replicate.

Read more about the book →